Search by typing & pressing enter
Order Your Cake Online Today!
Select Your Cake
Cookies & Cream
Birthday Cake Cookie Fudge
Cotton Candy Dream
Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl
Cone & Cake
Strawberries & Cream
Ice Cream Pizza - Cheese
Ice Cream Pizza - Chocolate Delight
Ice Cream Pizza - Supreme
Neapolitan Sheet Cake
Cookie Party Sheet Cake
Neapolitan Cherry Flower Sheet Cake
Please select your cake design. Picture references & prices are located at the top of the page. If you don't see your desired cake design, please visit the store or call 757-599-3996.
Select Your Cake Size
Small (serves 6-8 people)
Medium (serves 10-12 people)
Large Sheet Cake (serves up to 20 people)
Ice Cream Pizza (serves 12-15 people)
Availability of sizes may vary depending on your cake design. Please refer to the slideshow at the top of the page or call (757) 599-3996 to see if the cake design you desire is available in the size you want.
Message On The Cake (optional)
Special Instructions (optional)
If you wish to custom order certain flavors of ice cream, toppings, mix-ins, or cake base, please use this space.
Please note that we require 48 hours notice for
online cake orders!
If you would like a cake sooner than 48 hours, please call us at: (757) 599-3996 for available cakes already in stock
Desired Date For Pickup (MM/DD/YY)
Desired Time For Pickup
All custom cake orders must be paid for ahead of time. If you wish to complete your order over the phone, please exit out of this window & call (757) 599-3996
Credit Card Number
This number is the 3-digit code located on the back of your card.
By placing an order with City Center Ice Cream I hereby agree to pay the full price of the cake I have ordered and pick it up at the time I have specified. I hereby recogize that all custom cakes MUST be paid for ahead of time and failure to pay for the cake before the due date will result in my cake order being cancelled. If there are any issues with my cake or the payment method I have chosen, I hereby recognize that City Center Ice Cream will make all reasonable efforts to contact me using the information I have provided.
I agree to the terms & conditions
Terms & Conditions
Place My Cake Order
Proudly powered by